Can newcomers realistically make money selling on Amazon today? If so, is it best to start off with FBA or Merchant selling? We will have to start part-time and our goal is to move into full time in a years time. Is that realistic? We are a smart, creative hardworking couple. We are looking for honest, constructive feedback. We are rhings opposed to taking risks and we have some money to get started. My advice is really analyze and understand what niche you plan on selling in before you jump in. YES it is very possible for new sellers to make money on Amazon. Do NOT try to use any shortcuts .